See how The Scholar ranks against other hotels in City of Edinburgh

The Scholar in Edinburgh offers a generally positive experience, particularly highlighted by exceptional staff interactions, boasting a remarkable score in the Staff category. However, the hotel struggles in areas such as room quality, with subpar bathroom facilities and limited amenities impacting overall guest satisfaction. While location and food received mixed reviews, the prominent support for staff hints at a committed service culture that could drive future improvements across other categories, especially in dining and room comfort.