See how The Guards Hotel ranks against other hotels in City of Edinburgh

The Guards Hotel in Edinburgh presents a blend of strengths and weaknesses. While the hotel's location receives high praise, particularly for its proximity to public transport and attractions, guest experiences in the Room category highlight significant issues, especially with bathrooms and décor, leading to notably low scores. On a more positive note, the staff is well-regarded, particularly at reception, contributing to a generally satisfactory atmosphere despite the shortcomings in facilities and room quality. Overall, while there are appealing aspects, there is notable room for improvement to elevate the hotel's standing further.